July Fourth Bowl Review Sparks Ire

When a review of an American Independence Day Concert at the Hollywood Bowl (“Amber Waves Are Plain at the Bowl,” Calendar, July 4) begins with a quote from Samuel Johnson that “patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel,” it is clear that an attempt is being made by another writer to sneer at good, clean American fun.

What a pity that Timothy Mangan, although he admits that “we had fun,” felt compelled to try to out-Bernheimer Bernheimer. He needs to know that to do that requires wit, erudition and a sense of time and place--all of which the reviewer is lacking.

G. HENRY HOFER

Santa Monica

There is a mean spirit that emanates from the Los Angeles Times Calendar section. Artists are savaged on a regular basis with personal comments for no reason that I can fathom.

When Mangan, describing Marilyn Horne, added, “ . . . and aging mezzo-sopranos” to a quote by Samuel Johnson, he was being neither critical nor observant . . . not even clever. Just mean. How does that personal insult add to a review?

In the very next paragraph: “Marilyn Horne in the role of Kate Smith.” How dare he? Horne has been one of the greatest exponents of Rossini and the bel canto repertoire. Her credentials are many and authentic. Her artistry is legendary.

Finally, to address the sniggering overall tone of Mangan’s review. This is a Fourth of July pops concert! The event never pretended to be more than entertainment. Patriotic? Yes, it does seem appropriate on July Fourth!

B.J. WARD

Sherman Oaks