How Bandcamp became the anti-Spotify during the COVID age

Sept. 22, 2020 11:47 AM PT

Like thousands of artists, Nashville singer and songwriter Emma Swift faced a reckoning in March after all of her gigs were scrapped.

“When the pandemic hit, I lost my job as a touring musician. And in losing that job, I lost my primary income stream,” she said during a recent phone call. Pondering the prospect of releasing “Blonde on the Tracks,” her new folk-rock album of Bob Dylan songs, to major music streaming services minus any sense of when she’d be able to tour in support of it, Swift ran the numbers.

“It wasn’t actually going to be financially sensible or sustainable for me to release it on mainstream streaming platforms such as Spotify or Apple,” Swift explained. “I was only gonna be able to survive as an artist if I used a platform that would allow me to make money from the record.”

Like a skyrocketing number of independent artists, Swift went with Bandcamp. The platform, with its artist-first business model, has since its birth in 2008 become a player in the music streaming wars by celebrating niche communities while promising a radically transparent approach to royalties.

Born in Oakland with profits in part from the sale of an email start-up company, Bandcamp has thrived during a moment when the challenges facing musicians couldn’t be greater. Starved of road money and feeling abused or ignored by major services such as Spotify, Apple Music, Pandora and YouTube that pay fractions of a penny per spin, artists have flocked to Bandcamp and fans have followed. Launched as a digital music site, it has since become a merchandising powerhouse, connecting listeners with vinyl, CDs, cassettes and T-shirts.

Underscoring musicians’ needs, Bandcamp announced in March that once monthly, on each first Friday through the end of 2020, it would forgo its regular 15% cut on digital sales (and 10% cut of physical sales), in effect channeling 100% of money directly from fan to artist, often with as little as a two-day turnaround. Since then, fans have paid artists nearly $100 million.

All told, according to a tally prominently displayed on Bandcamp’s landing page, the platform has generated $584 million for artists since 2008.

“Spotify didn’t do anything to actually improve the financial situation for musicians out of their own pocket,” Swift said. Indicting Spotify’s billionaire founder and Chief Executive Daniel Ek as what she called “a morally reprehensible human being,” she added, “the music industry is in a really unfortunate situation where artists feel like they have to use those platforms or they’re not going to get their music heard.”

Bandcamp, by comparison, was founded on a basic question, says 49-year-old co-founder and Chief Executive Ethan Diamond. “If I love a piece of music, how do I get as close as possible to directly handing the artist some money? How do I do that and create that relationship with them?” He then repeats a mantra he’s recited in countless interviews: “Our success is tied to the artist’s success. We only make money if the artist makes a whole lot more.”

That approach has made it the rarest of tech companies: a beloved business that upends the market while coming across like some combination of consummately curated record store, laudably progressive nonprofit group and supersize first-generation music blog.

How did Bandcamp become the only music platform that everyone likes?

For starters, it’s a low bar, says digital music consultant Mark Mulligan of Britain-based media research company Midia Research. “Bandcamp has a lot of momentum and a lot of love, but that has as much to do with the weaknesses of streaming as it has to do with the strength of Bandcamp.” For one, unlike corporate-owned platforms such as Apple Music and Spotify, the latter of which is partially owned by the three major labels, the connection between musician and fan is virtually direct through Bandcamp.

That’s been essential since the arrival of the coronavirus. “Before the pandemic, an artist might not have made much money from streams, but the potential to reach hundreds of thousands of potential ticket buyers in advance of shows made the math work,” Mulligan says.

“The more people that could hear your music meant more people at concerts meant more people buying merch, and everybody’s happy. Take live out of the equation, and suddenly it doesn’t really add up,” he added. As the plight of their favorite musicians spread across social media, fans were eager to help.

“That’s exactly what Bandcamp has tapped into. People will go support their favorite artists on Bandcamp because they know they are making a statement of support,” Mulligan says.

It doesn’t hurt when Spotify’s Ek seems to blame artists for the oft-miniscule checks sent out by Spotify. In August, he took heat for stating that “some artists that used to do well in the past may not do well in this future landscape, where you can’t record music once every three to four years and think that’s going to be enough.”

The company Ek founded hasn’t hidden his larger intentions to move beyond music streaming and into podcasting, a not-so-subtle suggestion that he’s less concerned with increasing musicians’ fan bases than maneuvering into a realm where music is merely one vertical of a larger audio service.

Few artists voluntarily shout out the major platforms unless money is involved. By contrast, every time an independent artist complains about one of the corporate streaming services, a follower will no doubt guide them to Bandcamp.

One measure of the site’s virtuous circle? Well aware that their favorite artists could be struggling right now, more than 40% of buyers pay more than asking price at checkout. According to Bandcamp, which has 76 employees, in the past year fans have used the platform to buy 5 million digital albums, 2 million tracks, 1 million vinyl albums, 600,000 CDs, 300,000 cassettes and 250,000 T-shirts.

To get a sense of the site’s expansive aesthetic mission, check out some of the hundreds of Bandcamp Daily headlines it has published since launching in 2016.

“Eight Indie Bands to Know From Daegu, South Korea.” “How Galya Bisengalieva Mapped a Soviet Ecological Disaster With Her Violin.” “Seven Heavy Records Inspired by ‘Magic: The Gathering.’” “Skyzoo’s Hyper-Lyrical Underground Rap Is Still Going Strong After 20 Years.”

Hearing some of those headlines recited out loud, Diamond laughs. “I think sometimes that stuff can veer towards parody,” he says. “If it were only what you just said, then I would be like, ‘OK, this is ridiculous.’” He loves, however, that such niche features appear alongside the site’s most bankable editorial content: monthly roundups of more accessible genres such as the best jazz and hip-hop.

Diamond cofounded the company with programmers Shawn Grunberger, Joe Holt and Neal Tucker, and it is owned primarily by Diamond, Grunberger and Bandcamp employees. Aside from a round of venture capital in 2007 and 2008, the company hasn’t taken any money and has been profitable since 2012. It’s grown every year since. Over the past 30 days, Diamond says year-over-year sales have shot up by 122%.

He learned the art of frugality as he and a friend were launching the web-based email service Oddpost in 2000. Working first out of public libraries and coffee shops and then out of a Chinatown storefront in San Francisco, he cofounded the company with $60,000 he scraped together from friends and family. Within a few years, the partners sold the company to Yahoo for an undisclosed amount.

Bandcamp has had to push to break free of the perception that it’s an indie rock site, even if its earliest success came through young, independent artists unlikely to be approached by major labels but still hoping to earn a living in music.

J. Edward Keyes, Bandcamp’s editorial director, said that the goal of Bandcamp Daily when it launched was to steer the conversations toward avenues other than indie rock. The intent was “to build a platform that showcases the wide variety, not only of music that’s available on the site, but of the people who live in countries all over the world who are making their music available.”

A feast of music, the platform is the closest thing to crate-digging that the digital music sector has yet invented. Righteously egalitarian, the site’s focus has long been on exploration instead of competition. Where Spotify, Apple Music and Tidal emphasize the most popular tracks and albums through high-profile charts and playlists, Bandcamp’s charts are more diffuse.

That’s intentional, Diamond says. Calling bestsellers charts “self-reinforcing,” he believes that “a lot of times it just tells you where marketing dollars were spent, and that’s less interesting to me.”

Instead, Bandcamp encourages listeners to browse not by popularity or taste-making playlists, but by picking a subgenre, format, fan, label, location or some combination thereof. Unlike Soundcloud, which has generated its own rap subgenre, there’s not a Bandcamp sound. Songs don’t go viral on the platform. Rather, buyers swap tips, share purchases on social media or snatch up exclusives when artists send a Bandcamp alert.

“I have thousands of Bandcamp followers and people love the rarities,” says acclaimed indie rock singer, songwriter and guitarist Shamir Bailey, who performs as Shamir. “I feel like if you’re a Bandcamp follower, you’re a music nerd.” On Bandcamp Fridays since the pandemic started, the charismatic artist has been releasing songs and unreleased demos. He keeps them up for a day then pulls them down.

Shamir says that a few days after those Fridays, anywhere from a few hundred dollars to $1,500 has landed in his bank account. Those single-song, one-day Bandcamp sales are equivalent to a month’s worth of spins on Spotify. Sighing, he adds: “But we all know this. It’s not big news.”

Emma Swift covers Bob Dylan’s ‘You’re a Big Girl Now.’

For Swift, her “Blonde on the Tracks” gambit has paid dividends. “We sell an extraordinary amount of records on Bandcamp Friday,” Swift, who shares a home with the British singer-songwriter Robyn Hitchcock, said. “It’s enough for me to pay for a month’s worth of groceries. It keeps lights on in my house.” The Friday before she released “Blonde on the Tracks” in mid-August, she earned $1,400 in pre-orders through the platform. She earned another $1,500 on the first Friday of September.

Diamond said he never tires of such stories and that the company is “keenly aware of the important role Bandcamp plays in the livelihoods of many musicians, and that’s a responsibility we take very seriously.” It has also publicly supported human rights causes. On Juneteenth, for example, the platform donated its share of sales to the NAACP Legal Defense Fund. That and five other targeted fundraisers have earned $27 million toward charitable organizations.

(In March, Spotify launched its COVID-19 Music Relief project, which, according to the company, “recommends verified organizations that offer financial relief to those in the music community most in need around the world.” It has also recently added a tip jar as a way for fans to give directly to artists.)

Bandcamp has drawn so much attention that its success makes it ripe for acquisition. Asked whether he and the small ownership group would consider a sale or partnership, he turns diplomatic. “We would only consider partnerships with companies that we believe serve artists first and foremost, as we have for the past 11 years.”

He added later via email that before the pandemic, the company had regular meetups with artists and labels all over the world. He cited specific conversations that captured the feeling of many working musicians. “You’re our last hope,” read one.

Added another, “The world of right-minded musicians is depending on you. No pressure.”