Apple says no settlement talks with Qualcomm; San Diego federal judge sets trial date
A jury trial in Qualcomm’s wide-ranging legal war with Apple has been set to begin April 15 in San Diego federal court, with a settlement looking unlikely at this point.
U.S. District Judge Gonzalo Curiel scheduled the trial at hearing Friday. Qualcomm had sought to begin the trial in February, but Curiel said the April date was needed to accommodate the court’s schedule.
He also noted the complexity of the litigation and the prominence to the two tech giants as requiring more time.
Earlier this week, Qualcomm Chief Executive Steve Mollenkopf told CNBC’s Jim Cramer that the San Diego cellular technology firm was “on the doorstep of finding a resolution” to the dispute with Apple.
Some news outlets took Mollenkopf’s statement to suggest that the two sides were in settlement talks – though Mollenkopf has made it clear in the past that a “resolution” would come from either a settlement or a verdict in court.
Apple attorney William Isaacson told Curiel on Friday that a settlement wasn’t in the cards.
“The parties are going to need a trial,” said Isaacson. “There have been unfortunate articles lately that the parties are close to a settlement, and that is not true. There haven’t been talks in months.”
Since early 2017, Qualcomm and Apple have been waging a wide-ranging legal war over royalties that Qualcomm charges for use of its patented cellular technology.
It has been a fierce fight. Apple instructed Asian contract manufacturers that build iPhones to stop paying royalties to Qualcomm, and it ditched Qualcomm chips from its latest iPhone models.
Qualcomm has sought to ban iPhone imports in the U.S., Germany and China. It also has accused Apple of stealing trade secrets and supplying them to rival Intel.
Apple contends Qualcomm has concocted a scheme that allows it to overcharge for patents in violation of patent, contract and antitrust laws. According to Apple, Qualcomm is getting paid twice for its intellectual property – once when it licenses its patent portfolio and a second time when its sells cellular modem chips.
Qualcomm says there is nothing illegal about its business practices. The company contends not all of its 130,000-patents are encompassed on a cellular radio chip. It takes a system-wide approach to deliver fast wireless Internet connections to smartphones -- involving multiple components in phones and broader cellular network. Its extensive patent portfolio covers these system wide inventions.
A key battle is coming up early next year. The U.S. Federal Trade Commission has sued Qualcomm for antitrust violations along similar lines as the Apple lawsuit.
A trial in the FTC’s antitrust case is scheduled for Jan. 4 in U.S. District Court in San Jose. The outcome of that trial could play a role in the San Diego federal case. Qualcomm and the FTC have both said they are pursuing a settlement.
Qualcomm’s shares ended trading Friday up 15 cents at $58.26 on the Nasdaq exchange.
Business
mike.freeman@sduniontribune.com;
760-529-4973
