Banned books: from feel-good to dangerous
This article was originally on a blog post platform and may be missing photos, graphics or links. See About archive blog posts.
The British newspaper the Guardian, which has absolutely wonderful book coverage, has a post inspired by Banned Books Week here in America. Take this slightly bemused quiz about books that have been banned in the U.S. and around the world to measure the degree to which you’ve exercised your freedom to read (at less than 40%, my score was ‘Rather ignorant, I’m afraid’).
Banned Books Week began on Sept. 27 and runs through Saturday, Oct. 4. Many events are happening across Los Angeles, including an appearance by author Rick Wartzman on Thursday evening at Vroman’s Bookstore. He’ll be reading from, and discussing, his book ‘Obscene in the Extreme.’ It’s about the banning and burning of John Steinbeck’s ‘The Grapes of Wrath’ in 1939 in Kern County.
This weekend, L.A. Times books editor David L. Ulin urged us to think about Banned Books Week as more than just a celebration of challenged books that we like. ‘What happens when our ideals require us to defend a piece of writing that is reprehensible, that stands against everything we stand for?’ he asks, continuing:
It’s easy to condemn those who would remove ‘The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn’ from a library, but what about ‘The Turner Diaries’ or ‘The Protocols of the Elders of Zion’? Or for that matter, ‘Tintin in the Congo,’ which Little, Brown dropped from its ‘Tintin’ reissue series last fall after controversy arose about the book’s racist overtones?These are not just academic questions; they are the heart of the matter, regardless of where you stand on the ideological divide. How do we defend one book without defending all? Such a notion can’t help but make us uneasy, but then, that’s one of the most essential things books can do.
If you’ve made your peace with defending dangerous or even heinous speech, and if you were dubbed ‘a brave champion of liberty’ after acing the Guardian’s quiz, another front remains. For the second year in a row, the American Library Assn. is celebrating Banned Books Week in Second Life — the freedom to read needs defending, it seems, in our virtual worlds too.
— Carolyn Kellogg
