A HIGH PRICE TO PLAY : Liability for Football Injuries Causes Coaches, Manufacturers to Issue Warnings

Last week, Crespi High Coach Bill Redell assembled some 150 football players and issued this warning before allowing them to practice in helmets and pads:

“You may be permanently injured or even killed playing football.”

As the season approaches, coaches across the country will announce a similar message, and school officials might be there to note the date, time and place.

The possibility of multimillion-dollar liability suits stemming from injury or death on the field has coaches and administrators scrambling for protection.

“When an injury occurs, everyone’s first reaction is to sue everyone else,” said Richard Feldman, an attorney with Product Liability-Sports, a national organization that has begun lobbying for legislative reform in the area of sporting-goods liability.

Last February, a former Florida high school player paralyzed from a 1981 injury reached a settlement with the Riddell Co.--the country’s largest helmet manufacturer--that may award him as much as $14 million during his lifetime.

In 1982, in a case brought against a school district in Seattle, the court found that the plaintiff was entitled to damages because he hadn’t been adequately warned that he could become permanently disabled playing football.

“I call it a trend in the direction of informed consent, which is very similar to what happened in medical malpractice,” said Rick Ball, a former lawyer from Phoenix who specializes in insurance cases related to sports injuries. “When you obtain consent of parents and athletes you must give complete information or it’s not considered to be informed consent.

“A very commonplace claim by parents involved in lawsuits is, ‘I didn’t know this could happen in sports. If I had known this could happen, I never would have let my child participate.’ ”

Some schools now require parents and players to sign a detailed form indicating they understand the risk of injury in football. Others have mandatory preseason meetings where parents and players are shown videotapes that discuss fatal and catastrophic injuries.

Fred Mueller, the director of the National Center for Catastrophic Sports Injury Research in Chapel Hill, N.C., said there have been 53 high school fatalities directly related to football since 1977 and 78 permanent cervical-cord injuries. In addition, there have been 10 permanent cerebral injuries in the past three years.

“These types of injuries are down,” said Mueller, who added that the figures for permanently disabling injuries ranged between 25 and 30 a year in the early ‘70s.

In 1985, there were four deaths. A year later there were 11, eight of which resulted from head injuries and one from a neck injury, Mueller said. Last year was the first time since 1976--when there were 15 fatalities--that the national death figure has exceeded 10.

“We’re just hoping it was an off year and will come back down to the previous level,” Mueller said.

Coaches and manufacturers say football players have minimized the risk of injury by learning proper techniques. Today’s athletes also have been provided with safer equipment, but there’s a high price to play.

It costs an average of $400 to equip high school players, $550 for college players. Outfitting players ranges from $200 in youth leagues to $1,000 in the NFL.

Officials at USC and UCLA said they spend about $120,000 a year on equipment for games and practices.

Cal State Northridge and Cal Lutheran, which compete at the Division II level and spend about $15,000 each, have fewer players and less duplicate equipment than Division I schools. UCLA, for example, supplies about 100 players with four pairs of shoes and different helmets for games and practices. Northridge outfits 65 players with two pairs of shoes and one helmet each.

Meanwhile, junior college and high school coaches wrestle with budgets that have not kept up with increasing equipment costs, particularly for purchasing and maintaining helmets.

Paul Dunham, Moorpark College athletic director, said that in 1969 the school paid its football coach $12,000 and budgeted $5,000 for equipment. Since then, he said, salaries have tripled, but equipment allocations have remained the same.

Few Valley-area high school budgets would be adequate without booster club support. School-allocated funds for equipment range from about $2,000 at Westlake to about $11,000 at Crespi.

“When I started coaching as an assistant at Thousand Oaks High in 1970, the booster club was just for frills like pregame meals and that sort of thing,” Westlake Coach George Contreras said. “Right now, they’re fund-raising the basics.

“The school districts seem to have the feeling that if they cut back, the booster clubs will cover us.”

Regardless of budget size, it is generally understood that the cost of replacing equipment is going to be the biggest financial problem for a program to tackle each year.

In 1978, Westlake paid $45 each for 150 helmets, Contreras said. Today, the same helmet costs $100.

The price of helmets has increased and the number of companies manufacturing them has decreased for the same reason: The escalating cost of liability insurance.

Ten years ago, 15 companies manufactured helmets. Today, there are five.

Helmet manufacturers that have survived have passed on liability insurance costs to the purchaser. Scott Smith, a spokesman for Rawlings Sporting Goods Co., said about 30% of a helmet’s cost goes toward paying the manufacturer’s insurance.

“If a couple more companies go out of business because of liability there will be one of two alternatives,” said Skip Morris, administrative assistant for the Florida-based National High School Athletic Coaches Assn. “First, you’ll have mom-and-pop operations producing the equipment where the first time there’s an injury, they’ll fold up their tents and close shop.

“Then, if there’s no helmets, there will be no football.”

Reconditioning has taken some of the sting out of the rising cost of new equipment. Yogi’s Athletic Equipment Repair in Valencia tests and reconditions equipment for about 90 high schools and colleges between Fresno and Los Angeles.

When helmets and shoulder pads arrive at Yogi’s they are stripped down and inspected for cracks, rust, broken screws and other damage.

Helmets are tested on a Severity Index Analyzer, which measures resiliency according to standards set by the National Operating Committee for Safety in Athletic Equipment.

Part of the machine includes microchips encased in an apparatus that resembles a human skull. Each helmet is placed on the skull and dropped six feet onto an anvil. If the force on the skull exceeds 1,500 pounds per square inch, the helmet is discarded.

If a helmet survives, it is tested again--within 60 seconds--to simulate a game situation. Only if it passes the second test is it certified.

“We’ve had schools come in with 52 cracked helmets,” said Ed Luster, co-owner of Yogi’s. “In many cases, a lot of manageable problems like rust could be avoided if more coaches and players learned the proper way to store and take care of their equipment.”

Coaches, administrators and equipment manufacturers have learned, however, that in today’s litigious society, in order to take care of the players and protect them from injury--and themselves from lawsuits--they cannot afford to take shortcuts in purchasing, reconditioning and storing equipment.

“It’s just like a car,” said Nick Nichols, UCLA equipment manager, “If you don’t ever change your oil, well, it’s ‘Pay me now or pay me later.’

“It’s just like that in this business, too.”

FITTING THE BILL

Level Cost Pop Warner $190-225 High School $300-450 Junior College $400-500 College (Division II) $450-550 College (Division I) $500-600 Professional $700-1,000

Prices for equipment costs per player