Advertisement

ELOPING TO SCREEN, AFTER 43 YEARS

Share via

“Out of the headlines, onto the screen!”

That enticing old advertising pitch has never had a more likely candidate than Ellsworth Sonny Wisecarver, the subject of the current film “In the Mood.” But the leap from newspapers to theaters usually takes a little less than 43 years.

“I like to think of it as a story that was so hot, it took 40 years to cool down,” says “In the Mood” writer/director Phil Alden Robinson. “The story never really went away. It has stayed in the news.”

If you drift back 43 years, you end up in the stretch run of World War II, a time when women were on assembly lines, rationing was the daily grumble and a Japanese invasion of Southern California--by sea or by air--was a common fear.

Advertisement

There was an itch for diversion that even the jitterbug couldn’t scratch, and the press grabbed any good home-grown yarn and squeezed it like a wet tea bag.

Enter Sonny Wisecarver.

“Woman Who Eloped With Boy Hunted,” read the Page 1 headline in the Los Angeles Times on May 4, 1944, followed by this two-line deck: “Mother of Two Faces Charge of Stealing Neighbor’s Son, 14.”

The lean, lanky teen-ager from Willowbrook wasn’t exactly stolen. He had wooed and won 21-year-old Elaine Monfredi, and the two had run off in her common-law husband’s car and gotten married.

Advertisement

Wisecarver’s parents objected, and the marriage was interrupted one week into the honeymoon and annulled. But 18 months later, he was at it again, running off with a 25-year-old soldier’s wife named Eleanor Deveny. She also had two children.

The authorities were no more amused than Wisecarver’s parents. A judge ruled him incorrigible and sent him to a youth camp, from which he escaped.

“Wisecarver Still at Large,” the headlines said, as if warning men to get their wives off the street.

Advertisement

Later, there were photos of a sad-faced Sonny peering through the bars of a jail.

The media pinned him with a lot of labels--the “L.A. Lothario,” the “Compton Casanova,” the “Love Bandit.” But Life magazine came up with the one that stuck, describing him as “The Woo Woo Boy, the world’s greatest lover.”

If Hollywood had been as efficiently exploitative 40 years ago as it is today, Sonny Wisecarver would have had four agents, book and movie deals and more TV commercials than Donna Rice could dream of. As it was, he got only one offer, and Sonny’s parents turned it down.

“When it happened, someone approached my parents (about a movie) and they said, ‘No way, we don’t want nothing to do with it,’ ” recalls Wisecarver, now 58 and a confirmed single. “They were talking about Eddie Albert playing me.”

Wisecarver has spent 40 of the last 43 years in Las Vegas, installing telephones or driving tour buses and taxis. He now lives near Redlands, where he and a partner have a struggling 6-month-old telephone installation company of their own.

He says his life has been generally uneventful since he gave up older women. He got married for the second time when he was 17--to Betty Reber, also 17--and he was with her for 22 years. He left her when he was 40 to marry his third wife, a child bride of 20.

When that wife was 32 and he was 52, she dumped him.

Advertisement

“She grew up and said, ‘What do I want with this old man?,’ ” Wisecarver says, without a note of irony in his voice. “I didn’t handle that too well.”

Wisecarver may believe he “just drifted through life” without accomplishing anything, but the press begged to differ. Whenever anyone wrote a “Whatever happened to. . . ?” story, Wisecarver’s name seemed to come up. It was inevitable that someone would read one of these stories and revive the idea of making a movie about him.

Bob Kosberg and David Simon, a novice screenwriting team just out of UCLA, read about Wisecarver in a Times update in 1977 and started the chain of events that finally brought the story to the screen.

“We didn’t know what we were doing, we just read the story about Sonny and said, ‘This is great,’ ” says Kosberg, who is now a producer on contract with DEG Entertainment. “We called him up and said we’d like to buy the rights to his story. He said, ‘Come on over.’ ”

Wisecarver didn’t know what he was doing, either. After spending two days with Kosberg and Simon, recalling details from his “Woo Woo” days, he sold the rights to them for $500, plus 7% of whatever they made on the film.

“We found ourselves the proud owners of Sonny Wisecarver,” Kosberg laughs. “I never owned a person before.”

Advertisement

Kosberg and Simon, who is now a comedy writer on staff at Embassy Television, shopped Wisecarver’s story all over Hollywood and finally made a deal with Lorimar’s Peter Bart. They were paid to write a treatment and a script. In return, they conveyed Wisecarver’s story rights to the studio.

That made Lorimar the proud owner of Sonny Wisecarver.

Kosberg says Lorimar’s legal department told them they would also have to get the rights from the two older women in Wisecarver’s story, so in the best tradition of B movies, they hired a private eye to track them down. The detective found Monfredi, the first wife, and the young writers set up a meeting with her in a San Bernardino bar.

“The first thing she said was that she wasn’t going to sell us the rights until we got her a red Ferrari,” Kosberg says. “We thought that was it right there. It would never get done.”

Kosberg and Simon went ahead and completed their script without the women’s rights, but nothing was ever done with it. Meanwhile, the tour bus company that Wisecarver had worked for in Las Vegas went out of business and he was driving taxis.

It was another printed update on the Woo Woo Boy that revived the film project. Producer Karen Mack read an article by Mark Morrison in Los Angeles magazine and showed it to her partner, Gary Adelson.

“We both thought it would make a great movie, so we took it to Lorimar,” says Adelson, whose father, Merv Adelson, runs the studio. “We found out later that Bob (Kosberg) had written about the subject and that Lorimar already owned the rights.”

Advertisement

Adelson and Mack approached Phil Alden Robinson, based on his just-completed screenplay for “All of Me” and his original pre-Sylvester Stallone version of “Rhinestone.” Robinson says he wanted to direct his next movie, so he told his agent he wasn’t interested.

“My agent said, ‘Do me a favor, read this magazine article and if you’re still not interested, fine.’ I read about two articles and called him back and said, ‘Get me the job.’ ”

Robinson, who halfway through the writing won his argument that he should also direct, says he spent three days with Wisecarver and weeks in the library poring over original newspaper accounts.

“It struck me as being the funniest true story I ever read,” Robinson said, adding that every event in the film actually occurred and that courtroom dialogue and quoted newspaper accounts are verbatim.

The only fictional element, he says, was the condensing of events into a narrow time frame, a necessary compromise that first confused Wisecarver.

“I lived the period and it seemed disjointed to me the first time I saw it,” he says. “The second time, I enjoyed it much better.”

Advertisement

Wisecarver says he has been paid about $13,000 so far for his movie rights. Lorimar gave him a new contract when the film went into production and Robinson hired him to make a cameo appearance. He plays a mailman who delivers one line when asked what he thinks of the Woo Woo Boy.

“I think he’s a pervert and quite possibly a communist too.”

When Wisecarver showed up for his day’s work on the film, he brought his boss and his 11-year-old son, Michael, along. After all those years of talking about having a movie made on his life, he says he felt like he needed some witnesses to the fact that it was really being made.

Robinson, working independently, was unable to find either one of Sonny’s older women, so the names were fictionalized. In the movie, they are played by Talia Balsam and Beverly D’Angelo. Wisecarver is played by newcomer Patrick Dempsey.

Kosberg, who shares story credit on the movie with Simon and Robinson, says his meeting with Sonny’s first wife was a sad encounter.

“She was an unhappy lady; life had not turned out well for her,” Kosberg says. “She told us about the various men in her life after Sonny and she got very teary about it. She said none of them treated her as well as Sonny. It was serious soap opera.”

Everybody who has met Wisecarver on this film describes him in similar terms, as self-deprecating, modest, a good guy who deserved better than he got. But those weren’t the qualities that made him irresistible to older women 43 years ago.

Advertisement

“His appeal was simply that he treated these women better than anyone had ever treated them,” says Robinson. “He was considerate, he bought them presents, he asked for their opinions. He wanted to be a grown-up and he thought that’s what gentlemen did.”

Comedian Alan Sherman, writing satirically about the sexual revolution, said that the revolution began with Sonny Wisecarver. Robinson calls him America’s first liberated man.

Wisecarver calls his fame “a lot to do with nothing” and gets embarrassed when asked what he thinks made him the Woo Woo Boy.

“I have always been kind and considerate, in my opinion,” he says, haltingly. “I admire and like women. They are wonderful creatures. But I really don’t know why they liked me.”

Advertisement