Vatican denies pope has ‘Crusades’ mentality over genocide

Reporting from YEREVAN, Armenia —  The Vatican on Sunday strongly dismissed Turkish claims that Pope Francis has adopted a “Crusades” mentality by recognizing the Ottoman-era genocide of Armenians, insisting that Francis’ three-day visit to the Orthodox country was one of peace and reconciliation.

Francis wrapped up his trip with calls for closer ties with Armenia’s Oriental Orthodox church, a visit to its closed western border with Turkey and a joint declaration with the Apostolic Church leader. But it was his recognition on the first day that the Ottoman-era slaughter of an estimated 1.5 million Armenians constituted planned “genocide” that continued to reverberate.

Turkey issued a harsh rebuttal late Saturday, with Deputy Prime Minister Nurettin Canikli calling the comments “greatly unfortunate” and saying they bore the hallmarks of the “mentality of the Crusades.”

Turkey rejects the term “genocide,” saying the 1.5 million deaths cited by historians is an inflated figure and that people died on both sides as the Ottoman Empire collapsed amid World War I. When Francis first used it last year, Turkey recalled its ambassador for 10 months and accused the pope of spreading lies.

The Vatican spokesman, the Rev. Federico Lombardi, said the Holy See hadn’t received any formal complaint by Turkey as of Sunday. Responding to Canikli’s comments, he said that nothing in Francis’ texts or actions had suggested a Crusades-like mentality or spirit.

“It is a spirit of dialogue, of building peace, of building bridges and not walls,” Lombardi said.

“The pope is not doing Crusades,” he added. “He has said no words against the Turkish people.”

On Sunday, Francis turned his attention to more religious affairs, participating in an open-air liturgy at the Armenian Apostolic Cathedral in Etchmiadzin, the seat of the Oriental Orthodox church here. The landlocked nation of 3 million was the first nation in the world to adopt Christianity as a state religion in 301.

Amid haunting chants, Francis processed up and down the central walkway of the Etchmiadzin complex alongside the patriarch, Catholicos Karekin II, both walking under a gilded canopy as incense furled around them. During the two-hour service celebrated by Karekin, he stood to the side of the altar and offered a salute toward the end calling for greater unity between the two churches.

“May an ardent desire for unity rise up in our hearts, a unity that must not be the submission of one to the other, or assimilation, but rather the acceptance of all the gifts that God has given to each,” he said. “Let us pay heed to the younger generation, who seek a future free of past divisions.”

The faithful pray as Pope Francis leads the liturgy in the Armenian Apostolic Cathedral in Etchmiadzin.

(Zurab Kurtsikidze / EPA)

He then asked Karekin to bless him: “Bless me, bless me and the Catholic Church, and bless this path toward full unity.”

The Armenian Apostolic church and a few other Oriental Orthodox churches split from the Catholic Church in the 5th century in a dispute over the divine and human natures of Jesus Christ. The division arose from the Council of Chalcedon, some six centuries before the Great Schism that split the rest of Orthodoxy from Rome.

While still divided over the primacy of the pope, the Apostolic and Catholic churches have friendly relations and Francis’ visit here has been a visible testimony to their close ties: He and the papal delegation stayed at the Etchmiadzin cathedral complex as guests of Karekin.

But there have been tensions: Francis and Karekin were supposed to have signed a joint declaration on their improved ties at the end of the visit. For a few days, though, negotiations broke down and the declaration was taken off the agenda. With a few hours to go until the end of the trip, a text was agreed upon and was due to be signed by the two leaders, Lombardi said.

The two men also showed clear political differences during a prayer meeting Saturday night: While Francis spoke of the need for Armenians to move on to reconcile with Turkey, Karekin insisted in a fiery speech on the need for Turkey to acknowledge its past and for Armenians to find justice for past wrongs.

“Our people are grateful to your Holiness and to all who advocate for and protect justice, and anticipate that Turkey will demonstrate enough bravery to face its history to end the illegal blockade of Armenia and to cease from supporting Azerbaijan’s militaristic provocations targeted against the right of the people of Nagorno-Karabakh to live in freedom and peace,” Karekin said.

After Sunday’s liturgy and a formal luncheon, Francis was heading west toward Armenia’s border with Turkey for a visit to a monastery in the shadow of sacred Mt. Ararat.

Turkey closed the frontier in support of its ally and ethnic kin, Azerbaijan, after the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict erupted into a full-scale war in 1992. The blockade has worsened Armenia’s economic problems. Nagorno-Karabakh is officially part of Azerbaijan, but since a separatist war ended in 1994 it has been under the control of forces that claim to be local ethnic Armenians but that Azerbaijan claims include regular Armenian military.

Francis has said he would love to see the Turkish-Armenian border reopened, given his longstanding call for countries to build bridges, not walls, at their frontiers.

Francis is due to release a dove of peace near the border at the Khor Virap monastery. The monastery is one of the most sacred sites in Armenia and lies in the shadow of Mt. Ararat, where, according to legend, Noah landed his ark after the great flood.

ALSO

Pope approves measures to oust, but not prosecute, bishops who botch abuse cases

Pope’s visit to Greek island of refugees will be rich on symbolism as churches show unity

Pope Francis eases the way for divorced Catholics, but reiterates opposition to gay unions